After an accident

Dealing With Insurance After a Car Accident

Handling the insurance company is the part people find most stressful. Here's how it works: your insurer versus theirs, what you do and don't have to do, and how to avoid the common traps.

The short answer

  • Report to your own insurer promptly. Check your policy's notice terms. Reporting is not the same as making a claim.
  • You don't have to give the other insurer a recorded statement. It is fine to say you'll follow up once you have the full picture.
  • Stick to the facts and don't guess. "I don't know yet" is a safe, honest answer.
  • Don't accept the first offer on the spot. Early offers are often made before the full cost is clear.
  • Keep a paper trail. Photos, the police report, medical notes, and a record of every call.
In this guide
  1. The short answer
  2. Your insurer vs theirs
  3. Reporting vs claiming
  4. Recorded statements
  5. What insurers must do
  6. Valuing your claim
  7. First offers
  8. Keeping a record
  9. Do I need a lawyer?
  10. Common questions
  11. Sources

Most of the stress after an accident comes from dealing with insurance, but it gets much easier once you know the shape of it. This guide walks through it calmly. It pairs with what to do after a car accident.

Being cooperative and being careful are not opposites. You can be honest and helpful while still taking your time.

What is the difference between my insurer and the other driver's?

Your own insurer works under a contract with you, and that contract usually includes a duty to cooperate with its investigation. The other driver’s insurer works for its own policyholder. It may be polite and efficient, but it does not represent you, and you do not owe it the same cooperation. In particular, you are not generally required to give it a recorded statement, and it is reasonable to be more guarded with it.

Your own insurer (first party) The other driver’s insurer (third party)
Whose policy Yours The other driver’s
Your duty Cooperate with its investigation under the policy No policy duty to them
Statements May ask for a written or recorded statement You can decline or delay a recorded statement
Typical claim Collision, MedPay, uninsured motorist cover Property damage and injury claims against the at-fault driver
Who to complain to Your state department of insurance Your state department of insurance

The California Department of Insurance notes that your own insurance company will contact you for detailed information about the loss and may take a written or recorded statement. That is a normal part of the process. The point is to know which insurer you are talking to.

Is reporting an accident the same as making a claim?

No. Telling your insurer that an accident happened meets your policy’s notice requirement. It keeps your options open and does not commit you to a claim. You can decide about a claim later, once you understand the damage and any injuries. Policies differ on how quickly notice must be given, so read yours rather than assuming. The NAIC model regulation says an insurer should not deny a first-party claim for late notice unless written notice is a written policy condition, or the delay is so unreasonable that it breaches your duty to cooperate.

Do I have to give a recorded statement?

To the other driver’s insurer, generally not. You can decline or delay. If you do speak with them, keep it factual, do not speculate about your injuries before you have seen a doctor, and never feel pressured to answer on the spot. A calm “I’m not ready to give a recorded statement today” is acceptable.

To your own insurer, your policy may require cooperation, so a statement is more likely to be expected. Even then you can ask what the statement is for, answer only what you know, and ask for a copy afterwards. Our guide on what not to say to an adjuster has specific wording.

What does an insurer have to do after I make a claim?

Insurers are regulated by each state, and the rules differ. The NAIC publishes a model claims regulation that many states have used as a starting point. It shows the kind of standard to expect:

Step NAIC model regulation California regulation (one state’s example)
Acknowledge a new claim Within 15 days (Section 6A) Not covered here
Answer other pertinent communications Within 15 days (Section 6C) Not covered here
Accept or deny after proof of loss Within 21 days (Section 7A) Within 40 calendar days of proof of claim (§ 2695.7(b))
Pay an undisputed amount Within 30 days of affirming liability (Section 7F) Within 30 days of settlement (CDI brochure)
Offers Not to be labeled final or a release unless the limit is paid or a compromise is agreed (Section 5E) Not to be unreasonably low (§ 2695.7(g))

These are a model and one state’s rules, not a promise about yours. Ask your state department of insurance for the standards that apply where you live. If an insurer is missing them, a complaint to the department is a normal step.

The model regulation also says an insurer should not carry on settlement negotiations with a claimant who has no lawyer, where a statute of limitations could affect the claimant’s rights, unless it has given written notice of the limit. California’s regulation requires the notice at least 60 days before the limit expires and does not apply to claimants who have a lawyer. For the time limits themselves, see how long you have to file.

What goes into the value of a claim?

People often undercount their own claim, forgetting future medical costs, ongoing treatment, or time off work. Before accepting anything, make sure any figure covers the full picture, not just today’s bills: vehicle repair or replacement, medical costs so far and expected, lost income, and other documented losses. Our guide on who pays medical bills explains how MedPay, health insurance and liens interact, and car totaled: what next covers vehicle valuation.

Read nextWhat not to say to an insurance adjusterThe phrases that quietly weaken a claim, and what to say instead.

A man and a woman looking at paperwork together on a sofa
Check any offer against your real costs before you respond.

Why are first offers often low?

An early settlement offer is not the final word, and you do not have to accept it. If it does not cover your repairs, costs and any injury, it is reasonable to say you will consider it and respond later. Once you sign a release the claim is generally closed, so the order matters: understand your losses first, then decide. See should you accept the first settlement offer? for how to check an offer.

What records should I keep when dealing with insurers?

A simple log does more than memory under pressure. Our tools include an evidence checklist you can use. Keep:

  • Claim numbers and the name and direct number of each person you speak to
  • The date, time and a two-line summary of every call
  • Copies of emails, letters and anything you sign
  • Photos, the police report, repair estimates and medical records
  • Receipts for rental cars, towing and other costs

Do I need a lawyer to deal with the insurer?

Not always. A minor, undisputed property-damage claim is often handled without one. Advice becomes more useful if you were injured, fault is disputed, the insurer is not engaging fairly, or the offer does not match your documented losses. Our honest guide sets out both sides.

Honest guideDo I need a lawyer after a car accident?A straight answer, including the times you don’t.

Key takeaways
  • Report to your own insurer; reporting is not claiming.
  • You don't have to give the other insurer a recorded statement.
  • Stick to facts, don't guess, and don't speculate about injuries.
  • Insurers have claims-handling duties set by your state; a complaint to the department of insurance is a normal step.
  • First offers are often low; you can take your time, and signing a release usually ends the claim.

Common questions

Do I have to report the accident to my insurer?

Most policies require you to give notice of a loss, so check your policy's wording and report promptly whoever was at fault. Reporting tells them what happened. It is not the same as making a claim.

Can I refuse a recorded statement to the other insurer?

Generally yes. The other driver's insurer is not your insurer, and you are not usually obliged to give it a recorded statement. It is fine to decline or to follow up once you understand the full picture.

Do I have to give a recorded statement to my own insurer?

Your own policy may require you to cooperate with its investigation, which can include a written or recorded statement. Read the policy, answer factually, and ask for a copy of what you said.

How long does an insurer have to respond to my claim?

It depends on your state. The NAIC model claims regulation asks insurers to acknowledge a claim within 15 days and to accept or deny within 21 days of proof of loss. California's regulation allows 40 calendar days. Your state insurance department can tell you its own deadlines.

Should I accept the first offer?

Not necessarily. Early offers are often made before the full cost of repairs or injury is clear. Compare it against your documented costs and take your time.

Can the insurer tell me a payment is 'final'?

Under the NAIC model regulation, an insurer should not label a first-party payment as final or a release unless the policy limit has been paid or you have agreed a compromise. Read anything you are asked to sign before you sign it.

What is the difference between a first-party and a third-party claim?

A first-party claim is made on your own policy. A third-party claim is made against the other driver's policy. Different rules, deadlines and levels of cooperation apply to each.

Can the other driver's insurer pressure me to sign quickly?

The NAIC model regulation says an insurer should not tell a third-party claimant that their rights may be impaired unless a form or release is completed by a set date, other than to notify them of a real statute of limitations. Treat pressure to sign quickly as a reason to slow down.

What should I keep a record of?

Claim numbers, the name and number of everyone you speak to, the date and time of each call, copies of emails and letters, photos, the police report, repair estimates and medical records.

What if the insurer isn't being fair?

You can complain to your state department of insurance, which regulates claims practices. If you were injured, fault is disputed, or the insurer is not engaging, our guide on when advice is useful sets out your options.

Sources

Written by The Accident Advisory editorial team from the sources below.

  1. NAIC, Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation (MO-902), Sections 5, 6 and 7. Accessed
  2. California Code of Regulations, title 10, § 2695.7: standards for prompt, fair and equitable settlements (Cornell LII). Accessed
  3. California Department of Insurance, What To Do After an Auto Accident brochure (Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations). Accessed

The Accident Advisory provides free, general information and is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This guide is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for advice from a qualified attorney about your situation. Insurance rules and liability differ by state and by policy, and change over time.