After an accident

What Not to Say to an Insurance Adjuster

Adjusters are usually polite and professional, but they work for the insurer. Here are the phrases that quietly weaken a claim, and the calm, factual answers to use instead.

The short answer

  • Don't admit or speculate about fault. "It was my fault", or even "I didn't see them", can be used against you.
  • Don't say "I'm fine." Some injuries surface days later. Stick to "I'm getting checked by a doctor."
  • Don't guess. "I don't know yet" is a perfectly good, honest answer.
  • Don't agree to a recorded statement on the spot. You can decline or follow up later.
  • Don't accept the first offer. You can take your time to understand the full picture.
In this guide
  1. The short answer
  2. Why adjusters ask
  3. Phrases to avoid
  4. Recorded statements
  5. If you already said something
  6. What is safe to share
  7. The safe approach
  8. When to get advice
  9. Common questions
  10. Sources

Most adjusters are perfectly pleasant, and this is not about being difficult. It is simply that an adjuster is gathering information to decide what the insurer will pay, and a few off-the-cuff phrases can quietly undermine an otherwise strong claim. This pairs with our guide on dealing with insurance.

You don't have to be evasive, just factual. The safest answers are honest, brief, and free of guesswork.

Why do adjusters ask questions the way they do?

Adjusters are trained to gather information that helps value a claim, and sometimes to limit it. Friendly questions like “how are you feeling?” are normal, but an answer like “oh, I’m fine” can later be used to argue your injuries were minor. Knowing this lets you answer calmly and accurately. The California Department of Insurance advises saving your account for the police and your insurance company, and not signing statements about fault or promising to pay the other party’s damages.

Which phrases should I avoid, and what can I say instead?

Instead of this Why it can hurt Say this
“It was my fault” / “I’m sorry” Can be read as an admission of fault, which is decided from the evidence “I’d rather not discuss fault. The report covers what happened.”
“I’m fine” / “I’m not hurt” Later symptoms can be set against it “I’m being checked by a doctor and will know more soon.”
“I think it was about 40 mph…” A guess becomes a fixed fact in the file “I don’t want to guess. I’ll refer to the report.”
“Sure, you can record this.” You may be answering before you have your records “I’m not ready to give a recorded statement today.”
“That offer sounds okay.” Can be treated as acceptance “I’ll review it and get back to you in writing.”

Do I have to give a recorded statement?

To the other driver’s insurer, you are generally not required to give one, and it is reasonable to decline or to wait until you understand your injuries and have your records together. Your own insurer is different: your policy may require cooperation, and the California Department of Insurance notes that your insurer may take a written or recorded statement. In that case, answer only what you know, say so when you do not know, and ask for a copy of what you said. The full picture of who you owe what is in dealing with insurance.

A man and a woman looking at paperwork together on a sofa
If you were injured or fault is disputed, you do not have to handle the insurer alone.

What if I already said something I regret?

You have not lost your claim. A first conversation is not a contract. From here, stick to the facts, refer to the police report and your records, and correct anything that was wrong in a short written note so there is a dated record. If an insurer has misstated what you said, ask for the recording or transcript. Insurers are also held to claims-handling standards: the NAIC model regulation, for example, says an insurer must fully disclose to first-party claimants the benefits, coverages and provisions pertinent to their claim, and California’s regulation says an insurer must not make an unreasonably low offer. Your state insurance department handles complaints.

What is safe to share with an adjuster?

Being careful is not the same as being unhelpful. Adjusters need some information to move a claim along, and giving it promptly can speed things up. A sensible split:

Usually fine to share Better to hold back or check first
Your name, contact details and policy number A view on who was at fault
Where and when the accident happened Estimates of speed, distance or timing
The make, model and plate of each vehicle A statement that you are uninjured
That you are seeing a doctor, and the doctor’s name A diagnosis or prognosis before your doctor has given one
The police report number and the officer’s name Anything you are unsure of, or that you only heard from someone else
Where the car is and how to inspect it Agreement to a recorded statement, a release or a medical authorization you have not read

Two habits help. First, ask what the information is for before you give it. Second, send a short follow-up email after any call that confirms what was said and asks for anything promised in writing. The California Department of Insurance advises against signing statements about fault, and says to keep your account for the police and your own insurance company.

What is the safe approach, in one line?

Be honest, be brief, stick to the facts you are sure of, and when you are not sure, say so. Refer to the police report and your documentation rather than your memory of details under pressure. Put anything important in writing afterwards, and note the date, time and name of the person you spoke to. Our evidence checklist and the rest of our tools help you keep that record.

When should I get advice before speaking to an adjuster?

Not every claim needs it. If the damage is minor and nobody was hurt, you can usually handle it yourself. Advice is worth considering if you were injured, fault is disputed, the adjuster is pressing for a quick statement or release, or an offer looks well below your documented costs. Our honest guide covers both sides, and should you accept the first offer? covers what to do with a number once you have one.

Honest guideDo I need a lawyer after a car accident?A straight answer, including the times you don’t.

Key takeaways
  • Don't admit or speculate about fault, speed, or distances.
  • Don't say "I'm fine" before a doctor has checked you.
  • "I don't know yet" is a safe, honest answer.
  • You can decline a recorded statement to the other insurer, and the first offer.
  • Refer to the report and your records, not pressured memory, and follow up in writing.

Common questions

Do I have to talk to the other driver's insurance adjuster?

You can be cooperative, but you are not generally required to give them a recorded statement or to answer everything on the spot. Be factual, and it is fine to follow up once you understand the full picture.

Why shouldn't I say I'm fine?

Because some injuries appear days later. Saying "I'm fine" early can be used to argue your injuries were minor. "I'm being checked by a doctor" is more accurate.

Is it rude to decline a recorded statement?

No. It is a normal, reasonable thing to do, and a polite "I'm not ready to give a recorded statement today" is perfectly acceptable.

Should I write down what was said on a call?

Yes. Note the date, time, the adjuster's name and what was said, then follow up with a short email confirming it. A written record is easier to rely on than memory.

Does my own insurer's adjuster work for me?

Your insurer owes you the duties in your policy and in your state's claims rules, and you owe it cooperation. It is still the insurer's adjuster, so the same care with guesses and fault applies.

What if I already said something I regret?

Don't panic. Stick to the facts from here, refer to your documentation, and correct anything that was wrong in writing. If fault is disputed or you were injured, read our guide on when advice helps.

Should I sign anything the adjuster sends?

Read it first and ask what it is for. The California Department of Insurance advises not to sign statements about fault. A release ends the claim, so do not sign one until you know your full losses.

Can an adjuster tell me I must settle by a deadline?

The NAIC model regulation says an insurer should not tell a third-party claimant that their rights may be impaired unless a release is completed by a set date, apart from notifying them of a real statute of limitations.

What should I say when an adjuster asks how I am feeling?

Something accurate and short, such as "I'm still being checked by my doctor and will know more soon." Avoid both minimizing and exaggerating.

What can I do if I think an adjuster is being unfair?

Put your position in writing with your documents attached, ask for the reasons for any decision in writing, and contact your state department of insurance, which regulates claims practices.

Sources

Written by The Accident Advisory editorial team from the sources below.

  1. NAIC, Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation (MO-902), Sections 5 and 7. Accessed
  2. California Department of Insurance, What To Do After an Auto Accident brochure. Accessed
  3. California Code of Regulations, title 10, § 2695.7(g): settlement offers (Cornell LII). Accessed

The Accident Advisory provides free, general information and is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This guide is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for advice from a qualified attorney about your situation. Insurance rules and liability differ by state and by policy, and change over time.